Thursday, July 19, 2012

Can a judge order liens on pre-marital property to secure payments?

In the case of Mackoul v. Mackoul, 32 So.3d 741 (Fla. 1st DCA 2010) the court stated: 
PROPERTY TO SECURE ALIMONY AND CHILD SUPPORT, COURT ERRED IN FAILING TO MAKE SPECIFIC FINDINGS CONCERNING WHETHER THE LIEN ONLY SECURES ARREARAGES AT THE TIME OF HUSBAND'S DEATH OR IF IT WAS ALSO INTENDED TO SECURE FUTURE PAYMENTS IN ORDER TO MINIMIZE FUTURE ECONOMIC HARM TO THE FAMILY. 
The Husband appealed from a final judgment of dissolution of marriage which imposed a lien on his premarital real property to secure the payment of child support and permanent periodic alimony, because the order did not specify whether the lien was to secure arrearages at the time of his death or if it is also intended to secure future payments to minimize economic harm to the surviving family. The District Court held:
1. "Here, the record supports the trial court's imposition of a lien to secure the payment of alimony and child support. The Former Husband is 77 years old and in poor health. The Former Husband is uninsurable but has significant unencumbered assets that he uses to support himself. The Former Wife would potentially be left in dire straits after the Former Husband's death because she is not capable of full-time employment. The Former Wife has significant medical history resulting in some medical disability, and both parties agreed that the Former Wife needs to be home on afternoons and weekends to care for their youngest child, who has been diagnosed with a form of autism and cannot be left alone. The child also may remain dependant even after he reaches majority."
2. "Although the trial court did not abuse discretion in imposing a lien, the trial court failed to make any specific findings concerning whether, in the context of alimony, the lien only secures arrearages at the time of the Former Husband's death or if it was also intended to secure future payments in order to minimize economic harm to the family."
3. "Without such findings we are unable to determine whether the amount of the lien was appropriately tailored to the obligation being secured."
It is always a good idea to have a lien to secure future payments if there are available assets. 

No comments:

Post a Comment